The Insanity of Hope

I think there may be a fine line between insanity and hope. At first glance, these two concepts seem to be about as far apart as … Well, as two concepts can be. And yet, there’s a little bit of the raving lunatic inside all of us that convinces us to cling to hope. Madly, stubbornly, we grasp at it with clutching fingers, clinging to it by the very tips of our nails and with our last fraying nerve, if need be. After all, isn’t there a popular saying out there that defines insanity as “repeating the same mistakes and expecting different results”? But hope can be like that sometimes, too. We know someone we love will react negatively or say hurtful things when we share something new and exciting in our life — something that causes us such joy that it’s almost painful not to share it. Do we keep our joy a secret, knowing what we do? Or do we share it, anyhow, hoping that this time will be different. This time, we will find the love and support we’re seeking.

cherry blossoms: meadowlark botanical gardens, va

Somewhere — in some deep, dark, partially hidden place down inside of us, I suppose — we know it’ll never work. The response will be the same. It always has been, and, on some level, we know it always will be. And yet … And yet, there’s that teeny, tiny speck of hope. Maybe things will be different this time. Maybe this will be the time when she smiles, instead of looking hurt or disappointed. Maybe this will be the time he says he’s proud of you, instead of pointing out all the little ways in which you could have done better. It’s that little speck that keeps us coming back, time after time.

bishop's garden hinge: national cathedral, washington dc

So, when does hope stop being a good thing? Is there a point at which exuberant optimism slides into the depths of raving insanity?

crazy-fuzzy green plant: meadowlark botanical gardens, va

There is a rose bush that grows at the side of my house. I have no idea how old she is, but I presume she’s fairly old, as roses go. She was there when we bought the house. To use the word “bush” to describe her seems a bit ridiculous, as this plant is spindly and unattractive. In her defense, she hasn’t had the easiest time of it. She is planted in the shade of the house, so that she has lived most of her life in shadow, instead of the sun she must crave. No one, before we moved in, ever bothered to care for her. She was never trimmed back; her spent blooms were never deadheaded off during the growing season. No one fed her or removed the bugs and mold from her leaves. Even so, she continued on. She didn’t thrive, but she survived. Against all the odds.

one of my roses in the rain

When we moved in, I was dismayed to find that little rose bush, mostly buried beneath tall weeds and an overly bushy White Cedar Tree. I thought there was no hope for her, but I cleaned out her bed. I trimmed back the tree. Over the objections of different family members, who felt it was a waste of time and effort, I fertilized her and cleaned off the few pitiful leaves on her branches. I trimmed her back, working carefully because there wasn’t much space for new growth to occur.

my rosebush

That first year, not much happened, except my little rose bush lost all of her leaves. And I thought, for sure, it was a sign. I had been too late. The second year, she managed to regrow a few leaves. And a few new branches appeared. The third year, she produced a flower.


I know — one flower doesn’t seem like anything to be excited about. But this bloom … I’m not sure how to describe it. In a word, it was incredible. It was one of the most beautiful, most perfect roses I had ever seen. Pale pink, with layers and layers of delicately frilled petals, and nearly as large as the palm of my hand. It took me by surprise and took my breath away. It was so beautiful that I thought, surely, this was my little rose bush’s last gasp of life. Maybe putting all of her energy into this perfect bloom was her way of saying “thank you”. I thought this even more when the bloom died and, shortly after I trimmed it away, all of my plant’s leaves fell off. But, when the bloom returned the next year, I realized something. This is what hope is: that one delicate, fragile thing that keeps you going … that makes you keep on trying, even if it seems impossible.

roses, bishop's garden: national cathedral, washington dc

To this day, my little rose bush is pretty pathetic. She is the rose equivalent of Charlie Brown’s Christmas tree. She is spindly and lacking in leaves. Really, she resembles nothing more than a jumble of sticks jutting out from the ground at odd angles. Nearly everyone who sees her tells me to give up. They say I should pull that rose bush out, once and for all, so I can finally plant something “pretty”. And, truthfully, I think about it. I think about it every year, even as I trim her back and check her few leaves for aphids and mold. Each time, I wonder if this will be the year I’ll finally do it. Will this be the year I’ll finally give up on her? Will it be the year she finally gives up on me?

tattered butterfly: niagara falls, canada

But, every Spring, I hold my breath and wait. Sure enough, my little rose bush produces her one beautifully perfect bloom. I smile as I trim it away, trying to thank her with the gentlest of touches, hoping she can feel my joy and love. I take that bloom into my house so that I can cherish it — this perfect, amazing gift of love and hope. And I know: It’s not time to give up. Not just yet.


20 thoughts on “The Insanity of Hope

  1. I had tears in my eyes while reading this wonderfully eloquent and vivid post. You sure aren’t any ‘struggling’ writer, dear. You are supremely gifted and I hope you continue to enrich our lives through your words and thoughts.

    • Awwww, thanks! *blush* I’m really happy that folks liked this post. I’m very attached to that little, scraggly rose bush. It’s nice to know others can “see” her beauty, too, in a way. As always, thanks for your continued support. I appreciate it very, very much. 🙂

    • LOL — I had never thought about it that way before, either. But it just hit me the other day that those two states of being might be similar, in spite of one being perceived positively and the other negatively. Not any great wisdom on my part, though — just a weird way of looking at the world. (With pictures — ha ha! :D)

      Thanks, as always, for your support. I appreciate it very much.

    • Very!! I love the idea of hope, but I have often found it to be a fragile thing. I have a hard time hanging on to it. And often think I must be crazy to keep on trying for “hope” in any given situation.

      Thank you for your kind comment! 🙂

  2. I think you are on to something here, that hope and insanity are points along the same continuum. I think you are hopeful when you continue be open to others you love and who love you, and believe you may get a better response this time, or next time. Insanity comes is doing the harmful or negative thing over and over, with the conviction that this time nothing bad will happen.

    I love your rose bush story! (Which auto correct wants to change to rosé bush’ for some reason. Maybe it’s hoping that this time, someone will thank it with a nice glass of wine?)

    • I really like how you phrased things in your comment: that hope and insanity are on the same continuum, but, perhaps, at different ends of things. What a beautiful thought!

      Hmmm … I think my little, scraggly rose bush could probably do with a glass of wine. Perhaps it would help her grow some extra leaves or something — ha, ha! 🙂

      Thank you for reading, and for your comment. I enjoyed it very much.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s